When Zeke was a much younger fellow I tested his counting abilities. Hold up one finger, one bark. Two fingers, two barks. Spot on (pun intended) like that until he reached six at which point I switched back to one and he barked once. Two for two, three for three. A miracle! It was after reaching three that I paused to mentally add up the millions we'd be making on the Counting Dog World Tour. I was still holding up the three fingers...Zeke continued to bark. Seems that what he'd really been doing was barking as long as I held up fingers. Of course when he reached the right number I'd lower the fingers. A good trick, but not world tour worthy.
Well, at least Zeke is as clever as Clever Hans, the horse who got famous in Germany by 'counting' and solving simple math problems. It turned out that Hans was clever, but wasn't counting: he was listening for aural clues (the release of breath held in anticipation, say) from the people in the room to tell him when he'd reached the right answer.
It's funny you should post this today, because my brother and I were trying to determine if my dog can count last night, and so far he is no Clever Hans.
What test were you using for your dog?
Zeke has a low tolerance for tricks. I once spent weeks trying to get him to jump through a hoop (actually my arms held in a circle like a hoop). The most I could get would be one good hoop jump a day, any other attempts resulted in a flying body slam...whoops, missed the hoop.
I tried to show Faith this new trick but all Zeke would ever perform in public is the flying body slam.